My Roof Claim Was Denied in NJ: The 5-Step Appeal Plan with a Local Roofer

You pay your premiums every month for years. But when a storm finally hits your home in Deptford or Cherry Hill, your insurance company sends a letter saying “Denied.”

It feels like a betrayal. You are looking at a damaged roof and a massive repair bill you can’t afford. But here is the truth: A denial isn’t always the end of the road. Often, it’s just the beginning of the negotiation.

With the right evidence and a local expert like T.A. Hughes III Roofing by your side, you can often get that decision reversed. Here is your 5-step plan to fight back.

Why Do NJ Claims Get Denied? (The “Big 3” Reasons)

Before you appeal, you need to know why they said no. Usually, it comes down to one of these three reasons:

• “Wear and Tear” vs. Storm Damage: Adjusters often claim your shingles are simply “old” rather than damaged by wind or hail. While age matters, even an older roof is covered for storm damage.
• Lack of Evidence: “We didn’t see enough damage.” Adjusters sometimes stay on the ground or move too fast. They miss subtle damage that a trained roofer finds.
• The “Deductible” Trap: They might argue the repair cost is $900, but your deductible is $1,000. This is often because they are underestimating the scope of the work.

Read more: Why Your Insurance Claim Got Denied

Step 1: Decode the Denial Letter

Don’t throw the letter away in frustration. Read the specific “reason code.” You need to know if it is a Coverage Exclusion (your policy doesn’t cover that type of damage) or a Damage Dispute (they agree coverage exists, but disagree on how bad the damage is).

If it is a damage dispute, you have a very strong chance of winning an appeal.

Step 2: Call in the “Forensic” Roof Expert

An insurance adjuster works for the insurance company. We work for you.

T.A. Hughes III provides a comprehensive roof inspection. We don’t just look; we document. We take high-resolution photos of lifted shingles, granule loss, and hail hits. As GAF Certified roofers, we know exactly what damage voids a manufacturer warranty—something adjusters often ignore.

Schedule a Professional Roof Inspection Here

Step 3: Request a Re-Inspection (Meet on the Roof)

Once we have our evidence, call your insurance carrier and request a “re-inspection.” But here is the key: Do not let the adjuster go up alone.

Ask T.A. Hughes III to meet them there. It is much harder for an adjuster to deny damage when a professional roofer is standing right next to them, pointing directly at the cracks and creases. We speak their language and can explain why a simple repair won’t work.

Step 4: Submit “Irrefutable” Evidence

We help you compile a file that is hard to say “no” to. This includes:

• Date of Loss Proof: Weather reports proving a storm hit Camden County on the specific date.
• Professional Estimate: A detailed quote showing real local labor and material costs, not a lowball generic number.
• Photos: Detailed close-ups of every damaged area.

Need help starting? Check our guide: How to File an Insurance Claim Step-by-Step

Step 5: The “Nuclear” Option

If they still deny the claim after Step 4, you have two final options:

1. Hire a Public Adjuster: A Public Adjuster (PA) is a licensed professional who negotiates for you. They take a percentage of the final settlement, but they are experts at fighting denied claims. We can recommend trusted local PAs in South Jersey.
2. File a Complaint: You can contact the NJ Ombudsman or Department of Banking and Insurance if you believe the insurer is acting in bad faith.

Frequently Asked Questions

Don’t Fight the Insurance Giant Alone

A denial is just an opinion. It isn’t the final verdict. Call T.A. Hughes III for a free, no-obligation inspection. We will tell you the truth about your roof and help you fight for the coverage you deserve.

Get a Second Opinion Inspection